Tom Herman, Executive Director of the US National Council for Geographic Education, joined me from sunny San Diego – eight hours behind. We first met at the RGS conference earlier this year, and I knew then that we’d end up here. I just didn’t know how much of it would feel like therapy!
An identity built on observation, not rootedness
The classic Coffee & Geography opening question – how would you define your identity by geography? – revealed that Tom isn’t someone who’s from somewhere. He’s a product of observation: a Midwesterner by birth, schooled in a New Jersey suburb and downtown Washington DC, a couple of years in Las Cruces, New Mexico, and thirty-plus years in San Diego. He’s a self-described social, urban, cultural geographer who loves dense urban neighbourhoods and wilderness – “the longer you observe, the more the things are available for you to see” – while the suburbs keep everything hidden behind garage doors.
He put it best himself: “I’m more a product of close observation of all the places I’ve been.” Nobody actually functions in the world as we see it. We all make choices in a world as we understand it: partial, embodied, full of lived experience. Perspective and perception, not just space and place. Geography at its most human.
Two sides of the pond, same quiet squeeze
We compared our two very different routes to the same place. Over here, geography’s a standalone subject that’s felt squeezed for twenty years – and there’s a real worry that a new Natural History GCSE could become another nail in the coffin. Over there, it’s gone invisible: folded into social studies across fifty different state curricula, tacked onto courses called “history and geography” where the geography’s largely ignored.
And there’s a deeper problem hiding in those US standards. As Tom put it: “What environmental determinist wrote these standards?” Geography’s being used to explain why history happened – as if the environment makes people do things – rather than celebrating human agency. It’s the old trap we’ve unpacked on this podcast before.
The pond story
Regular listeners of the pod know I’ve told this story before, but it’s worth it. My old school was in a village of 800 dwellings that was doubling to 1,600, with new housing estates going up right opposite the school gates. So instead of teaching urbanisation from a whiteboard, I took the kids to the edge of the school grounds and asked them what they thought. What’s it doing to you? What are your parents saying?
One young student came back a few weeks later, walking her dog around the local woodland ponds. She’d noticed the water level dropping, and normal weather, nor drought, couldn’t explain it. “Do you think this has got anything to do with the new houses, Mx?” I honestly hadn’t thought about it. She got her parents involved, we did the research, and it turned out the construction was interfering with the water table. The ponds had newts, fish, a community that loved them – and they were livid. With very little prompting from me, that girl helped spark her family and community to force an order: the developers had to fix the water table and regenerate the ponds at their own expense. They’re still there and now properly cared for, fifteen years later.
I’ve never seen a young person so fired up in geography. She wasn’t just learning it, she was also living it. Tom’s takeaway was the one I wanted everyone to hear: “Put them in a position that is consequential, and then they will take ownership of the inquiry.” Or, in his words: “Coverage and content are the enemy of learning.” The people learning need greater importance than the things we want them to learn. I’ll never tire of that.
Personal geographies
It’s why I always brought geography down to the personal — the unit I called personal geographies. You don’t need the terminology to explain how it feels to walk the dog around your local ponds. You just need someone to ask. As Tom said, people don’t realise they’re geographers. And geographers don’t realise they’re poets.
Geography Awareness Week
The timing of this one’s perfect: the episode released on Saturday 14th November, just before Geography Awareness Week (16–20 November, themed “Mapping the Future”), with GIS Day on Wednesday 18 November. NCGE has a special GIS Day webinar on a curriculum and lesson-development platform that helps teachers turn local data into real community inquiries – exactly the pond-detectives stuff we’re talking about. It’s all at ncge.org, and it’s open to international members too.
Spilling the Beans
This month’s Spilling the Beans was a good one. Tom was born the day the astronauts returned from the first moonwalk. The youngest of five, Granddad the State Engineer of Michigan, Dad an engineer on the Apollo project who was mildly irritated that Tom’s late arrival meant he missed the astronauts’ welcome-back party. The drafting tables in the cartography lab turned out to be Tom’s bridge into geography (and yes, I kept my 1960s light-up drafting table against all advice. Old tech is best). It’s also a lovely nod back to Amy Imhoff’s episode and our Artemis II moon flyby.
The daisy chain
Edward Ofori-Annor handed Tom morphology, and he ran with it – shapes, negative space, the layered morphologies of acculturated space. In return, he’s passed playfulness to the next guest: “the way in which people construct the most durable knowledge.” You can see every word so far in the word cloud at geogramblings.com – everything from Kuroshio to toenail, minerals and collagen.
This is one of those episodes you’ll want to share with a teacher. However you get your podcasts – those links are below.
🎧 https://soundcloud.com/geogramblings/coffee-geography-620 🎥 https://youtu.be/-8tVuu4rebc 🔗 NCGE: ncge.org 🔗 Geography Awareness Week 2026: ncge.org/geography-awareness-week 🔗 GIS Day: gisday.com
